
One summit, three leaders and a war that is nearly five years old – here is where the peace push stands today.
The Russia Ukraine peace talks have entered a tense new phase. After meeting US President Donald Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping at the APEC summit in Shenzhen, Russian President Vladimir Putin has gone back to the security demands Moscow first made in 2021. Ukraine and European leaders, meanwhile, warn that the new talks could weaken NATO and reward Russia.
Key Highlights
- Putin says Russia is open to discussing Europe’s security with European countries, as the US has suggested.
- Moscow is again pointing to its December 2021 draft treaties that asked NATO to stop expanding east.
- Ukraine wants any ceasefire to include firm security guarantees for Kyiv.
- EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas says a ceasefire must come before wider security talks.
- US envoy Jared Kushner says Trump is open to NATO-like guarantees for postwar Ukraine.
What Putin Said After Shenzhen
The Shenzhen meeting was the first three-way meeting between Trump, Xi and Putin, and it ended with the joint “Declaration toward Peace”. Speaking afterwards, Putin criticised the West for ignoring Moscow’s concerns about NATO expansion and dismissed European objections in sharp language.
He said it makes no sense to discuss European security without the Europeans, and that Moscow has invited a European delegation to explain its position before the date and format of Ukraine talks are fixed. Putin added that Russia is ready to look for compromise but will not give up its key demands. He has also warned that any European troops sent to Ukraine after the fighting ends would be treated as a legitimate target.
The 2021 Demands Are Back on the Table
According to The Associated Press report on Moscow’s demands, the draft agreements Russia sent to the US and NATO in December 2021 – two months before the invasion – covered these main points:
| Russia’s 2021 demand | What it would mean |
|---|---|
| No NATO expansion to Ukraine, Georgia or other ex-Soviet states | Kyiv stays outside NATO |
| No Western weapons or military activity in ex-Soviet states | Limits on military support to Ukraine |
| No NATO troops where they were not present in 1997 | Pullback from Central and Eastern Europe |
| Fewer drills and more transparency | Lower risk of incidents in the Baltic and Black seas |
NATO allies rejected these demands as a nonstarter at the time. Kremlin adviser Yuri Ushakov said Putin reminded US envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner of the proposals during their November 12 talks in the Kremlin, and that Moscow would now add “fresh considerations”.
What Ukraine, Europe and the US Say
Putin describes the West’s refusal of his 2021 proposals as the main reason he sent troops into Ukraine in February 2022. Ukraine and its allies call the invasion an unprovoked act of aggression. President Volodymyr Zelenskyy has warned that talking about a new European security framework before the war ends could be dangerous, because Moscow could use it to weaken NATO and reshape borders.
We actually walk into the traps that Russia is setting us.
Kaja Kallas, EU foreign policy chief
From Washington’s side, Kushner said after meeting Zelenskyy and European leaders in Berlin that Trump wants a deal with Europe by his side and is not trying to impose one. Trump himself told reporters at the White House that Putin wants to end the war through diplomacy. Hours after the summit, however, Ukrainian authorities reported a large Russian missile and drone attack.
Analysts are divided. A pro-Kremlin commentator argued there is wide room for compromise on arms limits and monitoring, while Carnegie expert Tatiana Stanovaya expects the process to deepen divisions within Europe.
FAQs
What did Putin say after the Shenzhen summit?
He said Russia is open to European security talks with Europeans, is ready to compromise, but will not drop its key demands.
What are Russia’s 2021 demands?
No NATO expansion to ex-Soviet states, no Western military activity there and no NATO troops where they were not present in 1997.
What does Ukraine want?
Kyiv wants a ceasefire backed by a security framework that stops Russia from attacking again.
Can the Shenzhen talks lead to a real ceasefire? Share your view in the comments below.
Details as reported by The Associated Press and IANS.
